Dogs & Laws

Are We Being Lied To? Merrick, Purina, Fromm, Others Sued Over ‘Made in USA’ Claims

dog and food

Pet food manufacturers must create food that adheres to AAFCO (The Association of American Feed Control Officials) standards. In order to meet these standards, they often purchase vitamin and mineral premixes from another company.

Dogs Naturally explains:

But here’s how pet food manufacturers can trick us into believing the ingredients our dogs are eating are sourced in the US when they’re probably not …

… if the vitamins and minerals from China are mixed together in another country, and then added to the food, the manufacturer doesn’t have to come clean on the Chinese ingredients because they weren’t added directly to the food. And if the premix was mixed up someplace other than China, the pet food manufacturer can claim there are no dangerous Chinese ingredients in the food…

So, while reputable and premium pet food manufacturers make reasonable attempts to source the highest quality ingredients for their food and treats, it’s nearly impossible to determine where every single ingredient originated.

In defense of their pet food, several companies including Evangers, Stella & Chewy’s, Solid Gold, and Red Moon Pet Foods have explained that it’s impossible to source every single premix ingredient from the U.S. and that any company making that claim is lying.

To see how your pet’s food manufacturer responded to questioning regarding the country of origin of their vitamin/mineral premixes, see this report from Truth About Pet Food.

In response to this lawsuit, Merrick Pet Care and Castor & Pollux told us the following:

“We are aware of this lawsuit and believe it to be baseless. We fully comply with labeling laws for our made in the USA, high quality, natural pet food recipes. We plan to vigorously defend our brand.
It is important to note that nothing has changed about how we source ingredients for our Merrick or Castor & Pollux recipes. All of our recipes are made in the USA, and the majority of our ingredients come from within the United States with the exception of those ingredients that we cannot get here in a quality, consistent supply (for example, New Zealand lamb). And, of course, we never go to China for our ingredients. 

We recognize that it’s important for pet parents to understand where the ingredients in their pet food come from, and we encourage pet parents to reach out to us if they have questions about specific ingredients in our recipes.”

So perhaps the problem lies in that pet food labeling laws are written in a way that allows a manufacturer to make misleading claims?
How important is “Made in the USA” label to you when you choose your dog’s food? CLICK NEXT
2 of 3
Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse


1 Comment

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To Top
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest dog news, recall alerts, and giveaways!

You have Successfully Subscribed!